Book Club Blues

book_questionmarkBook Club meets on Sunday. I’m the moderator this month, the one who leads the discussion. I want it to be a lively dialogue, a reflection on the various themes, the research, the eloquent writing. I want to hear how people related to the characters, the relevance the story had   on members’ own lives, the nuggets of Truth that were found on its pages.

There’s only one problem: I hated the selected book.

As an author myself, I squirm at making such a bold and unkind remark about a book. I know the author toiled – probably for years – at writing it. (It is oh-so-long.) I know how hard it is to write a book, even a short, simple story. The blurbs by other best-selling authors on the jacket praise this book, saying it is the writer’s best work to date, and she has published dozens of books. I tend to be open-minded in my reading tastes, enjoying a vast variety of genres and writing styles. I always try to understand what the author is trying to say, and I respect creative attempts at getting the message across, even when they are less than successful.

But not this time. If it hadn’t been a book club selection, and if I hadn’t paid good money for it, I would have quit after page 10. The story got bogged down and repetitive immediately. I didn’t want to turn the page, and there were about 500 of them to turn. I am so grateful that I wasn’t the one who make the selection, I’d feel so guilty that I’d made all the other book club members slog through it. But that’s the way it is in book club, you make a selection based on good reviews and word of mouth, hoping they aren’t misleading.

At book club meetings we often find that our initial scores of a book (out of a possible 10) tend to go up after the discussion. We hear how the story moved other members, and why they liked it. Rarely do our scores go down, as it’s in the discussion that we often discover the hidden beauty of a story, especially if it has particular relevance to another book club member.

I hope that is the case this month and that I can report back that my score went from a lowly 2 to a possible 5. I secretly challenge my book club friends to help me see the merit in this story.

Please, let it be so.


2 thoughts on “Book Club Blues

  1. There’s a discussion in itself, can book reviews be trusted? That’s one of the reasons I like the crowd-sourcing approach of sites like good reads. I used to write book reviews for the BCTLA journal and found it one of the most challenging things I have ever done.

    • Good point Lesley. I also used to write reviews, for a little newspaper called The Vancouver Child. There were so many books to choose from that I only reviewed books that I loved or thought were ‘important’. That made it a lot easier.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s